FX Week Europe: 'Patchy' liquidity in FX a concern for the future
A reduction in the number of liquidity providers in foreign exchange is creating an unstable market environment that could put the industry in a dangerous position in the event of another financial crisis, according to senior industry officials who spoke at the FX Week Europe conference in London on Wednesday.
Discussing the regulatory constraints facing the market-making capacity of banks as well as the rise of non-bank market-makers, both buy-side and sell-side traders expressed concern that high-frequency trading firms might provide significant liquidity in the good times, but won't necessarily be there when markets turn sour.
"The issue is not really what they're trying to do; it's that they might not be there the whole time. I have no problem with that – just don't call it liquidity. The market has moments when liquidity falls away and comes back again and it's a lot patchier than it's been historically. There are fewer market-makers and less risk capital being deployed, and you're already seeing the consequences in the market. The concern is that in the event of another crisis, my gut tells me it would be unpleasant," said Kevin Rodgers, global head of FX at Deutsche Bank in London.
"There is no question there has been an impact on liquidity as many of these new market-makers will only participate when there is liquidity rather than during low-liquidity times in the market," added Claude Goulet, head of FX and commodities institutional sales for Europe, the Middle East and Africa at HSBC in London. "So to an extent it's slightly dangerous, and we know for a fact this will be exploited and increase the fragmentation of the market. The cost and organisation of being able to do business now means you will need to have even more capital, so you might have to widen the price ultimately and provide liquidity in a very different way."
The concerns of the banks were echoed by Paul Chappell, founder and chief investment officer at currency management firm C-View, who said that, from a buy-side perspective, the lack of bank market-makers is a deep concern as fewer participants are able to warehouse risk. He also expressed concerns over the decline in liquidity in non-deliverable forwards (NDFs) following the launch of US swap execution facilities (Sefs) on October 2.
The market has moments when liquidity falls away and comes back again and it's a lot patchier than it's been historically
"Six to nine months ago in the NDF market there was considerable activity across a wide spectrum of players in regards to market-making and market-taking. What's happened since the rolling out of Sefs is that there has been fragmentation, and that means it's not as possible to aggregate pricing," said Chappell.
Panellists also discussed the move to central clearing of FX products, and the publication last week by the global FX division of the Global Financial Markets Association of a key paper that revealed the same-day liquidity shortfall facing central counterparties clearing physically delivered FX options could be as high as $161 billion.
"I have to be honest, it did surprise me that the number was quite that high, but they did a huge amount of work, taking data from dozens of banks and analysed it thoroughly for some time," said Rodgers.
"What it shows is the gigantic size of the FX market, and the very physical nature of it. FX grew up as an over-the-counter market because people needed to transact cash from one place to another. That means that the overall challenges of the FX market tend to be mainly around settlement risk rather than credit risk. We have an industry solution for that – CLS – so exactly where clearing fits into this whole equation is much more difficult to see. That's why years are passing and we're not getting to where I think the law drafters imagined we'd get to by now."
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@fx-markets.com or view our subscription options here: https://subscriptions.fx-markets.com
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@fx-markets.com to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@fx-markets.com to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (point 2.4), printing is limited to a single copy.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@fx-markets.com
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (clause 2.4), an Authorised User may only make one copy of the materials for their own personal use. You must also comply with the restrictions in clause 2.5.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@fx-markets.com
More on Trading
Forward thinking: Banks adapt P&L mark-out tools for FX forwards
Dealers modify market impact measurement to get better handle on profitability – and client value
BNP Paribas to launch e-FX pricing engine in Singapore
BNPP is latest bank to set up Singapore pricing engine; readies Cortex Live launch with AI and data tools
JP Morgan: beating lower margins, flat volumes and the competition
Foresees collaboration with clients and technology providers on FX tech infrastructure, and working with regional players
FX market growing, but more risky – BIS review
Reduced reliance on PvP and heightened fragmentation threaten market resilience
BidFX eyes expansion in execution tools and algos
Buy-side focus on FX exposure will drive development
Call for clarity on last look rejections
Asset managers say holding periods “far in excess” of what is necessary for risk checks
Buy-side traders cannot be passive with algo execution
Traders need to be proactive and ensure in-depth monitoring throughout life of an order, panellists say
FXall bolsters frontier liquidity with new partnership
The alliance will extend liquidity to several currencies in Africa and Asia